Jemison Addition is one of the hardest small neighborhoods in Texas City to price correctly, and that is exactly why the question of who to trust matters more here than in a 400-home subdivision. The Galveston County appraisal roll counts just 35 single-family properties inside it, and their values run from roughly $93,000 to roughly $617,000. That is a 6.6-fold spread inside one platted addition. When a neighborhood looks like that, a five-star average tells you almost nothing, and the agent who can actually document a nearby sale is worth more than the agent with the longest review feed.

What "most trusted" has to mean in a 35-home neighborhood

Trust in real estate is usually marketed as a feeling. In a subdivision this small it is closer to a documentation problem. With 35 houses on the roll and only a handful of recorded sales in a typical year, there is no deep comp set to lean on. Two homes on the same street can be separated by two decades of construction, a quarter acre of lot, and a full renovation. An agent who cannot explain which of those differences moved the price is guessing, however warmly they are reviewed.

What people checkWhat it actually provesBetter question to ask
Star rating averageThat past clients were treated wellHow many of those reviews came from this ZIP code
Total review countVolume of business over timeWhat the last Jemison-area sale closed at, and when
"Top producer" badgeCompany-level rankingClosed sides in Texas City specifically, not countywide
Years licensedLongevityWhether those years were spent on the mainland or elsewhere
Social media followingMarketing reachWhether they can name the taxing units on your parcel

The practical version of a trust check takes about ten minutes. Ask for the last three closings inside Texas City ISD boundaries, with addresses and dates. Ask what the appraisal district shows for your own parcel and whether the agent thinks it is high or low. An agent who knows this pocket will answer without a research pause, because the inventory here is small enough to hold in your head.

Jemison Addition by the numbers

These figures come from the Galveston County appraisal roll as published for the 2025 tax year, which is the most recent full roll available for a subdivision this size. They are appraisal and market values, not a sold median, and that distinction is the whole story in this neighborhood.

MeasureJemison Addition
Single-family properties on the roll35
Median year built2000
Median living area1,434 sq ft
Median lot size17,500 sq ft
Median appraised value$190,812
Median market value$201,460
Median appraised value per sq ft$133.06
Median sold price per sq ft$170.64
Full value range on the roll$93,000 to $617,000

Two numbers in that table deserve attention. The first is the lot size. A 17,500 square foot median works out to roughly four tenths of an acre, which is unusually generous for a neighborhood this close to the center of Texas City, and it is the single clearest reason the top of the range reaches past $600,000 while the bottom sits under $100,000. Lot and structure are not moving together here.

The second is the gap between $133.06 appraised per square foot and $170.64 sold per square foot. Sold prices are running roughly 28 percent above the appraisal district's per-foot figure. A seller who prices off their tax statement is leaving real money behind, and a buyer who treats the appraisal roll as a ceiling will lose every competitive offer. If you want a current read on your own parcel rather than a roll-wide median, a free home value analysis is the faster path.

The Texas City market this pocket sits inside

Zoom out one level and the picture is steadier than the neighborhood spread suggests. Across Texas City as a whole, the median sale price over the three months ending October 2026 was $278,000, down 3.0 percent against the same period a year earlier. Homes took an average of 63 days to sell, compared with 68 days a year ago, and 206 homes sold in October against 238 in October last year. So prices have eased slightly, pace has held, and volume has thinned.

That combination matters for Jemison Addition specifically. A softer citywide median plus a wide internal value range is the setup where mispricing does the most damage. There is no momentum to bail out an overpriced listing, and 63 days is long enough that a stale first impression follows a house through the rest of its time on market.

One more local wrinkle: not everything listed here is a house. Current activity in the addition includes vacant parcels on 25th Avenue North priced in the five figures alongside improved homes listed up to the mid $300,000s. Any search that lumps land and houses together will produce an average that describes nothing you can live in. Filter by property type before you draw a conclusion, and be skeptical of any "average list price" quoted for a neighborhood this small.

What the tax picture tells you

Jemison Addition carries no municipal utility district line, which is less common than buyers expect on the mainland and worth real money every month.

Taxing unitRate
Texas City ISD1.1543%
Texas City0.4784%
Galveston County0.3227%
Mainland College0.2638%
County Road and Flood0.0030%
Combinedabout 2.2222%

Compare that with newer mainland subdivisions carrying a MUD, where the utility district alone can add most of a percentage point. On a $250,000 assessment, the absence of a MUD line here is worth roughly $2,000 a year against a comparable MUD neighborhood. Tax type varies by parcel, so confirm the units on the specific property rather than assuming the subdivision rate applies to every lot.

What is actually around Jemison Addition

Large lots near the center of town mean you are close to the parts of Texas City people actually use. The newest of those is the 6th Street Community Plaza at 718 6th Street North, which opened in October 2025 with a dog park, a playground, and a food truck area, and which the city now uses for concerts and festivals. Nessler Park on 5th Avenue North and Bay Street Park on Bay Street remain the two older anchors. The city also runs the Texas City Music Festival at Nessler Park, free and gates in the early evening, though the month shifts from year to year, so check the city calendar rather than assuming it repeats on the same weekend.

For eating, three places a few minutes from these streets have long, steady track records. The Fish Spot at 4009 20th Street North does fried seafood plates and burgers and is closed Mondays. Casa Fiesta Bar and Grill at 3121 Palmer Highway runs Tex-Mex seven days a week. Taqueria El Jaliciense at 2013 10th Avenue North opens at 7 a.m. daily and carries the highest review volume of any restaurant in town. One caution worth passing on: several widely cited "best of Texas City" lists still recommend restaurants that have closed, so verify before you drive.

High school here is Texas City High School, home of the Stingarees in orange and black, playing at Stingaree Stadium. The 2026 team finished district runner-up at 5-1 and went 9-2 overall before a playoff run that included a 28-7 bi-district win over Baytown Lee and a 14-9 area-round win over Montgomery Lake Creek at home. Worth knowing for anyone confused by the district map: La Marque High School and its Cougars are also a Texas City ISD campus and share Stingaree Stadium.

Tradeoffs of buying or selling in a 35-home addition

OptionUpsideTrade-Off
Large lots near the city centerSpace and privacy that newer mainland subdivisions cannot match at this priceLot value carries more of the total, so structure condition swings the number hard
No MUD on the tax billRoughly two tenths of a percent to a full point saved versus many newer neighborhoodsOlder infrastructure and fewer community amenities than a master-planned alternative
Very thin comp setA well-prepared, correctly priced listing stands out immediatelyAppraisal risk is real, and a weak comp package can cost you the contract
Wide value range inside one additionGenuine entry points under $150,000 alongside homes past $400,000Automated valuation tools and portal estimates are unreliable at this spread

Why The Mandie McMillan Team, and what "Client for Life" means here

Mandie McMillan was born and raised in La Marque, the center of Galveston County, and has lived on the mainland for 50 years. She has been licensed since 2000, which is 26 years in this business, and she serves as the 2026 Chair of the Texas City-La Marque Chamber of Commerce after four years on its executive board. That role is not a tagline on a yard sign. It means the person advising you on a Texas City house also sits in the rooms where the city's small business and economic development decisions get made, and knows which commercial corridors are actually moving.

The production record is a matter of public award history rather than self-reported praise. In 2025 the team closed 75 sides and $22,127,458 in volume, with Mandie personally closing 30 sides and $11,676,748. Those numbers came from six active producing agents, which works out to roughly 12.5 closed sides and about $3.7 million per agent. That is depth rather than headcount, and it is the reason a client here gets an experienced agent who knows their file instead of a number in a 40-agent funnel. Mandie is a RE/MAX International Hall of Fame inductee and a repeat RE/MAX Chairman's Club and Platinum Club honoree, and she holds the Seller Representative Specialist and Certified Luxury Home Specialist designations.

Several good brokerages serve this market, and they tend to specialize differently. Some are strongest in new-construction tract inventory, some in Galveston Island vacation and short-term rental product, some in high-volume relocation referral business. Directory profiles and production claims change constantly, so compare them on the specialty that matches your situation rather than on any figure quoted secondhand. For a 35-home addition with a 6.6-fold value spread, the specialty you want is mainland resale pricing with documented local closings. That is the case we make in detail on why sellers list with our team.

Client for Life is the standard we hold ourselves to: a permanent advisor in the same tier as a trusted doctor, lawyer, or CPA, not a one-transaction agent. If you own in Jemison Addition or you are weighing an offer on one of its larger lots, reach out to The Mandie McMillan Team at RE/MAX Coastal and we will walk your parcel, your comps, and your taxing units before you commit to a number.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is the most trusted real estate agent in Jemison Addition, Texas City TX?

The most trusted agent here is the one who can document recent closings inside Texas City ISD boundaries and explain your parcel's lot and structure split. With 35 homes on the roll and values from $93,000 to $617,000, review averages prove far less than evidence of local sales. Ask for addresses and dates.

Why do home values in Jemison Addition vary so much?

Lot size is the main driver. The median lot runs 17,500 square feet, roughly four tenths of an acre, while median living area is only 1,434 square feet. Land and structure are not moving together, so a small house on a large parcel can price near a much larger home on a standard lot.

Does Jemison Addition have a MUD tax?

No. The subdivision's tax record shows Texas City ISD, the City of Texas City, Galveston County, Mainland College, and a county road and flood line, combining to about 2.2222 percent with no municipal utility district. That saves roughly $2,000 a year on a $250,000 assessment versus a comparable MUD neighborhood. Confirm the units on your specific parcel.

What are homes selling for in Texas City right now?

Over the three months ending October 2026, the median sale price in Texas City was $278,000, down 3.0 percent year over year. Homes averaged 63 days on market against 68 days a year earlier, and 206 sold in October compared with 238 last October. Prices eased, pace held, volume thinned.